Home Page
Progressive News
Health Care & Wellness
Media & The Blogs
National Issues
Candidates & Causes
Poverty & Economics
Environment & Science
Education & Opportunity
Equality Rights & Issues
International Issues
Rants & Raves

About us
Who We Are
Community Guidelines
Getting Started
Formatting Tips
FAQ
Contact Us


New Blogroll coming soon

Progressive Issues for "more and BETTER" Democrats
"Health care is a fundamental right." (Ted Kennedy, 8/26/08)
* * * * * * *
Support Rescue/Rebuliding in Haiti
Red Cross | CARE | Doctors Without Borders
YELE | International Rescue Committee | Partners in Health


Feeling the spirit of political rules

by: Chino Blanco

Sun Jul 20, 2008 at 22:42:13 PM EDT


By Derek Price
With Permission

When The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints recently announced it would jump into California politics by supporting a constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage, many Mormons - including myself - were appalled.

Some members were upset that their tithing donations would be used to support a political agenda with which they disagree. Others were disappointed to see the church once again veer from its hollow claim of "political neutrality." And some found it laughable that the LDS church, which was founded by people with famously liberal marriage arrangements, is now taking a "one man, one woman" stance.

Isn't that a little ironic?

Really, though, this isn't just an issue about Mormons, gays and the California Constitution. Aside from the unpleasant thought of individual religious groups trying to force their doctrine upon all people through the enactment of civil law, there's another reason churches should stay out of politics.

It's all about the money.  

Chino Blanco :: Feeling the spirit of political rules
You see, when churches decide to turn themselves into de facto political committees, they flout America's campaign finance laws that are designed to keep the flow of political money transparent and limited in scope. While politically active churches may comply with the letter of the law, they definitely don't comply with the spirit. That gives them an unfair advantage.

If I were to donate to a political action committee or 527 group, for example, there are three major drawbacks compared with giving to a church. One, my donation would not be tax-deductible. Two, my money would be precisely tracked - and made public - because of campaign reporting requirements. And three, the law limits how much money I'm allowed to give.

Churches, though, don't have those limitations. When I give to a politically active church, I get a tax break. The money is also collected and spent in complete secrecy without any public tracking or accountability, and there's no limit to how much I can donate.

That's a little unfair, don't you think?

That's why whenever churches decide to play the political game - which I wish would never happen - they ought to at least abide by the same rules as everyone else. If they don't, they turn themselves into a money-laundering operation whereby contributions are made completely anonymously, then spent in unknown ways to influence public policy.

No matter where you stand on the issue of marriage freedom, it's wrong for any organization to flout America's already lax campaign finance rules by operating in darkness.

Let's hope the Mormon church sees the light. The church should either abide by the same restrictions as all political groups or - gasp! - let its members make up their own minds about which political issues to support.

---

* DEREK PRICE is a newspaper editor and lifelong Mormon living in Alabama.  

Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
What's Sunday without a little scripture? (3.00 / 2)
And just for today, let's make it a little Mormon scripture:

http://scriptures.lds.org/en/d...

We do not believe it just to mingle religious influence with civil government, whereby one religious society is fostered and another proscribed in its spiritual privileges, and the individual rights of its members, as citizens, denied.

D&C 134:9


Derek: 'people can post this wherever they want' (3.00 / 2)
As such, might this be a useful Letter to the Editor to your local newspaper?

I question whether (3.00 / 3)
these churches becoming political aren't unconstitutional.  We still have a country that supposedly believes in separation of church and state.   I certainly don't want to be subjected to the influences of even to well intentioned religious groups in politics.

US Casualties-Afghanastan Can click date link to see by date.


The imperative is to define what is right and do it. Barbara Jordan


Like Derek, I think what concerns me most is the money ... (3.00 / 2)
The means by which money gets funneled to initiatives like Prop 8 are so varied and so opaque and so pervasive that I gave up trying to write about what I'd found (where to start?  once you start digging, the sheer volume of suspect activity that never gets properly investigated becomes overwhelming).  For example, the case of Marriage Education Initiatives:

http://deseretnews.com/article...

MEI seems to have blatantly broken the spirit and letter of campaign rules, but once the election's over, you never hear from or about them again.

Of course, MEI is peanuts compared to the potential hazard posed by the fact that nobody, not even the most faithful Mormons, has access to LDS financial disclosures, because there are none.  No rank-and-file Mormon, and none of us, has any idea where that 10% of members' income that the church collects is actually being spent.  As far as I'm aware, that's entirely constitutional ... but for anyone who values an open and fair political process, it's extremely troubling.      


[ Parent ]
The Yes on 8 coalition is already unraveling ... (3.00 / 1)
How soon after the Prop 8 battle do Evangelicals (3.00 / 2)
go back to picketing Mormon temples?

Just wondering.

I mean, considering that it's only July, and the ProtectMarriage.com folks are already characterizing their fellow travellers, Campaign for California Families, as a bunch of extremists, I'd guess we could expect to start seeing those pickets again some time around, say, November 5th.


clarification (3.00 / 3)
I guess I'm a bit confused.  While I gather you are from CA, I'm not sure if you are upset just by Prop 8, the Mormons, the opposition to homosexual marriage or the religious right (maybe all of the above).  Can you clarify please?

US Casualties-Afghanastan Can click date link to see by date.


The imperative is to define what is right and do it. Barbara Jordan


[ Parent ]
With pleasure (and thanks for intervening in my rant ;-) (3.00 / 3)
- LA (Pasadena) was my last home before relocating to Asia.  Currently have a sister and nephew at UCLA.  That's the extent of my CA connection.

- I would be opposed to Prop 8 regardless of who was supporting the initiative.

- That said, when I became aware of the letter that was read over (nearly) all California Mormon pulpits on June 29th, I felt compelled to engage.  I served an LDS mission in Brazil.  After returning, I continued my studies at BYU and had the 'pleasure' of watching good friends deal with coming out in that environment.

-  The PR outfit (Schubert Flint Public Affairs) hired by the Yes on 8 coalition is run by GOP political operators like Jeff Flint who worked at Move America Forward to sell the Iraq war to the American people.  That the LDS Church would support a campaign that is paying guys like Jeff to run it is disturbing to me.

- I am troubled by the marriage of convenience between the Mormons and groups like the Trinitarian Christians (Falwell's bunch) that's been arranged for the purpose of supporting Prop 8.  I'm all for interfaith dialogue between Mormons and Evangelicals (e.g. Richard Mouw), but hearing from Mitt Romney that Falwell went to Salt Lake to meet the LDS leadership to set the Prop 8 strategy is not something that I think would sit well with many Mormons ... as with abortion, Mormons and Evangelicals have their own beliefs, which may be close enough to cobble together a political coalition, but are distinct enough that being in the same coalition together rubs plenty of folks the wrong way.

Oh my.  I guess I could've just said "all of the above" ...



[ Parent ]
Thanks. (3.00 / 2)
I appreciate the clarification.

US Casualties-Afghanastan Can click date link to see by date.


The imperative is to define what is right and do it. Barbara Jordan


[ Parent ]
If $'s the nub, can we even get there from here? (3.00 / 2)
I find it frustrating that I can pop over to the UK and find more LDS financial disclosure than I can in the USA (where there's effectively none, zip, nada).

http://www.charity-commission....

Whatever one may think of this utter lack of disclosure requirements here in the USA, at least it means that we all start from the same place when discussing LDS finances:  the dark.


Gratuitous plug (3.00 / 2)
As long as I'm here, just wanted to add, this site gives me hope:

http://signingforsomething.org...


that is very hopeful (3.00 / 2)


[ Parent ]
if you liked that, here's some more ... (3.00 / 1)
Another letter to the SL Tribune:

As a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, I support same-sex marriages ...

http://www.sltrib.com/Opinion/...


[ Parent ]
The Good News is that (3.00 / 2)
According to the latest Field Poll, this Proposition is going down 51% to 42%.
I fully expect more of my time & energy will be spent in CA to defeat this Proposition that seeks to create unequal rights based on Gender Preference.

It is a PDF:

http://www.field.com/fieldpoll...


(-8.50/-7.44) "If you want others to be happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion." Dalai Lama


Front Page Feed:
Menu
New here?
Make a New Account

Have an account?
Log in:

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


A stirring tale of how progressives built America and lessons on creating the next Big Change Moment, from OpenLeft's Mike Lux.

"As inspiring as it is informative." -Arianna Huffington

"Mike is that rarest breed: a populist insider." -Wes Boyd

"Better than an OpenLeft flame war." -Chris Bowers

Search




Advanced Search
Active Users
Currently 1 user(s) logged on.

Progressive Blue
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

Since 02/29/2008
Powered by: SoapBlox